Sugartown Cemetery, Franklinville
Extracted From
Gravestone Inscriptions In
Cattaraugus County, New York
Including Cemeteries In & Near the Towns of
Freedom, Franklinville & Yorkshire

Compiled by Mrs. Gertrude A. Barber
1930 [Typescript, no copyright statement]

[Transcribed by Jane Devlin]

Sugartown Cemetery in the Town of Franklinville, Cattaraugus County, N.Y. This Cemetery is right beside the Sugartown Baptist Church. It is well fenced but is not taken care of. WALRATH Walter, 1826-1899 (soldier) Mary, wife, 1828-1908 Elizabeth, wife of David, d. 7 Jun 1873, ae 87-3-23 CLEVELAND Aaron, b. 3 Feb 1821, d. 5 Feb 1899 Catharine, wife, b. 16 oct 1832, d. 14 Aug 1904 Brainard, b. 15 Apr 1788, d. 5 Jun 1857 Betsey _., wife, b. 14 Feb 1792, d. 6 Nov 1847 Mary A., b. 12 Aug 1826, d. 20 Aug 1847 CHASE Jonathan, d. 25 Sep 1846 Adelaide Watrath, d. 31 Oct 1851 CHOLLETTE Fidelia McIntosh, b. 7 Feb 1818, d. 2 Nov 1908 CHASE Nellie, d. 19 Mar 1870, ae 1 mo. HARRISON Alena, wife of C. H., b. 1 Mar 1851, d. 2 Oct 1887 COCKRAN Jane D., 1857-1874 Nettie M., 1871-1874 HOAG Mildred, b. 7 Apr 1873, d. 5 May 1892 TORRANCE (no given names or dates) FRANK James D., 1832-1904 Sarah, 1837-1878 Carrie, d. Apr 1863, ae 4-1-24 JOHNSON Emma C., wife of John, Co. H., 154 Reg., 1828-1909 Jacob, b. 2 Mar 1800, d. 15 Feb 1884 Margaret, wife, b. 28 Jun 1801, d. 20 Nov 1887 BERRY P. O., d. 9 Apr 1888, ae 72 Christina (no dates given) FOSTER Edward, b. 27 May 1833, d. 9 Sep 1888, Co. H, 37 Regt. N. Y. S. Vol. Inf. BALL Asa, 1855- Lettie, wife, 1861-1904 Stanley, 1892- Cora, 1894-1910 FOLTS Lyle, 1922-1924 Catharine, 1902-1909 Vernice, wife of Floyd, d. 28 Dec 1905, ae 27-7-16 JONES Oliver A. 1836-1909 Betsy A., 1845-1913 WATKINS Ira D., 1864-1910 Addie E. Simons, wife, 1870- JOHNSON John A., Co. H., 154 Reg. N.Y.V., 1827-1911 McKAY Oscar, 1839-1917, Co. C, 64 Reg., N. Y. V. Adaline M., wife, 1841-1914 CHAMBERLIN Frank, 1830- Ada J., d. 11 May 1897, ae 8 dys Alta E., 1863- KEIR William, b. Balgonia, Scotland, d. 21 Nov 1879, ae 68 Janet T., wife, b. 24 Aug 1820, at Lauriston, Scotland MORRISON Andrew, d. 18 Aug 1869, ae 72 Janet, wife, d. 1 Feb 1872, ae 77 Bertha, dau., d. 20 Sep 1890, ae 9 mos, 15 dys Andrew, d. 23 Jun 1840, d. 26 Apr 1916 Jennie, wife, b. 11 Aug 1849, d. 19 Mar 1901 Bertha J., b. 5 Dec 1882, d. 20 Sep 1890 CLARK M. B., dau. of V. H. & E. C., d. 22 Apr 1894, ae 10 mos, 17 dys JONES Frederick, 21 Jun 1854, 40 yrs, 2 mos Permelia, his wife, 1816-1904 DARROW Martha, 29 Oct 1885, 75 yrs Robert, 31 Oct 1863, 67 yrs, 11 mos, 29 dys Betsey E., his wife, 12 Nov 1863, 66 yrs, 5 mos, 8 dys Benjamin (stone broken) EVANS Sylvester, 9 Jul 1818 - 8 May 1890 Mercy, his wife, 1 Jan 1831 - 23 Oct 1897 BARROW (DARROW?) William, 14 Jul 1831 - 2 Nov 1900 ROOT Noah M., 16 Nov 1820 - 9 Aug 1877 Betsey E., his wife, 30 Mar 1828 - 28 Feb 1906 STILLMAN Sally, wife of Erastus, 28 Apr 1864, 57 yrs, 6 mos, 25 dys CHICKERING Dr. Calvin, 15 Nov 1846, ae 39 (38?) yrs Calvin, 1809-1916 REED Dr. Virgil, b. 1814, d. 1906 Caroline Crary, wife of Chickering REED, b. 1810, d. 1901 Frank H., b. 1849 CRARY Dr. Clark, b. 1811, d. 1859 H. Hale, b. 1815 Archie C., b. 1819 NELSON Jane Ann Crary, wife, b. 1823, d. 1848 HICAR Emma, her daughter, b. 1845 CRARY Dr. Eugene, b. 1826, (no death date) BRAYNT Huldah, wife of A. C. & C. B., 1820-1866 CRARY Harmon A., b. 1817 Elbert A., b. 1849 Freeman E., b. 1857 (1851?) Clark S., b. 1853 Augustine, b. 1856, d. 1861 William, 1712-1796, Revolutionary Patriot Nancy Campbell, his wife, (no dates given) Archabald CRARY & 4 sisters (no dates given) William, 1759-1828, Revolutionary Patriot Sarah Ann Spencer, his wife, 1767-1851 Spencer, 1783-1846 Lucy, 1784-1861 William, 1785-1859 Augustus M. L., 1787-1867 Benjamin, 1789-1796 Percilla Hale, wife of Dr. A. CRARY, b. 1784, d. 1861 McKOON Rev. Newton, 1835-1906 Ann Crary, 1845-1914 CRARY Benjamin, 29 Jul 1811 - 4 May 1890 Rhoda, his wife, 25 Mar 1815 - 19 Jan 1882 Sophia, 1822-1911 GODDING Mary, wife of William CRARY d. Croton, N. Y., 21 Aug 1829, ae 44 yr CRARY William, 11 Apr 1859, ae 73 yrs, 3 mos, 24 dys WRIGHT Frederick, 8 Jan 1819 - 12 Apr 1882 Richard, 15 Oct 1851, ae 65 yrs CRARY Betsey, wife of Spencer, 14 Sep 1851, ae 56 yrs Sarah Ann, wife of William, 23 Sep 1854, ae 85 yrs Elbert, son of A. C. & H. S., 15 Dec 1849, ae 4 mos, 20 dys Infant, same parents, 19 Jan 1851 Spencer, 21 Sep 1845, ae 61 yrs Dr. C., (no dates given) NELSON Jane Ann, wife of George B., 23 Feb 1848, ae 25 yrs CRARY H. H., 1815-1837 WRIGHT Franklin, son of Richard & Polly, d. 7 Oct 1850, ae 8 yrs, 21 dys Polly, wife of Richard, 20 Oct 1799 - 31 Mar 1875 HALL Ralph, Jr., 6 Nov 1825, 58 yrs, Revolutionary Patriot Mary, his wife, 1 Sep 1825, 52 yrs CAMPBELL J. A., 5 Dec 1871, 56 yrs, 27 dys Permelia, his wife, 1820-1905 DICKERSON John W., 16 Nov 1844, ae 70 yrs Charles F., Jun 1851, ae 56 yrs, 15 dys Sandstone (no dates given) SCOTT John, 1816-1903, Co. I, 6 N. Y. Cav. (no dates given) Oliver, 14 Mar 1857, 42 yrs, 10 mos, 4 dys Albert, 13 Feb 1859, 9 yrs, 6 mos, 10 dys MORGAN James, son of Hiram & Harriet, 30 Aug 1871, ae 31 yrs, 19 dys, Co. H, 37 Vol. Hiram, 15 Feb 1808 - 25 Oct 1864 Harriet, his wife, 17 Apr 1812 - 26 Jun 1887 Phidelia, 7 Oct 1852 - 5 Jan 1875 Phidelia, dau., 5 Jan 1874, 22 yrs, 3 mos Hiram, 25 Oct 1864, 56 yrs, 8 mos, 10 dys BOND Joseph, 10 Aug 1830, ae 3 yrs, 6 mos Lucy, 26 Mar 1841, 9 yrs, child of Dea. James & Laura BOND HEWITT Hannah, wife of Thomas, 12 Aug 1849, ae 66 yrs, 4 mos GARDNER Stephen, 22 Apr 1855, ae 84 yrs George, 10 Nov 1837, ae 22 yrs, 11 mos, 4 dys Horatio D., 9 Apr 1852, ae 1 mo, 7 dys Delbert D., 16 Jul 1859, ae 8 yrs, 3 mos, 20 dys Decater C.,, taken prisoner, 2 Jul 1863; d. in Bell Island Prison, 18 Jan 1864, 37 yrs, 3 mos, 23 dys CALKINS L. D., (no dates given) MYRICK Hattie, wife of Eugene, 2 Dec 1857 - 17 Oct 1885 WIDRIG Conrad, 1843-1915 Harriet Ayer, 1847-1915, wife FOLTS Morris W., 1847-19__ Nina C., wife, 1843-1917 DAVIS George W., 1856-1920 KRIEGER Daisy, 1920 Josephine, 1918 OAKS Edgar D., 8 Nov 1856 Hattie, wife, 7 Nov 1863 - 6 Feb 1908 Raymond H., 1908-1924 Irving C., 1898-1916 Hattie E., 1881-1912 BOWEN Rev. I. L., 1833-1908 E. A. Dean, wife, 1825-1921 Clark F., 1840-1920 Olivia O., dau., 1845-1918 Elias (flag) (no dates given) Lucinda, wife, 9 Jan 1887, ae 70yrs, 3 mos FULLER F. W. & L. A. (no dates given) Claud, son, 25 Feb 1893, ae 8 wks WIMPLE Charles T., 14 Dec 1844 - 19 Mar 1875, Co. K, 81st N. Y. S. Vol. (flag) SLOCUM Threasa, 1873-1922 WOODARD Robert J., 1843-1917 Atcelia, 1845-1907 (flag) MOORE Edgar L., 1856-19-- Hattie E., 1859-1926 JOHNSON Stephen T., 1829-1909, Co. G., 188 Reg. Achsah, wife, 1837- PUTNAM J. M. C. P., (no dates given) Elsie, wife, 31 Jul 1890, ae 45 yrs, 9 mos, 11 dys Infant son, 10 Aug 1882, ae 4 mos, 10 dys Joseph, Co. H., 154 N. Y. S. V., 1857-1929 Grace, wife (no dates given) John M., 1863-1928 PERSONS Ephram P., 1807-1885 Helen Laidlaw, 1802-1879 WILSON Joseph G., 1843-1924 (flag) Julietta Harney, 1846-1907 Claude J., 1878-1917 WEATHERLY Charles, 1829-1909 Cornelia, wife, 1848-1908 Sandstone - P. F. G. DAVIDSON Thomas, 1832, 59 yrs Susan, 1823 - --- Lucy, 1878 (1870?), 84 yrs CLIFFORD G., 1842-1901 Mrs. M. E., 7 Sep 1884 RIDER Abbie, wife, 25 Jun 1892, ae 30 yrs, 10 mos, 4 dys Wm. Fox, (no dates given) VAN SLYKE Egbert, 1851-1902 Lora A., wife, 1851- ---- Clinton O., son, 1873-1875 Bertha, dau., 1880- ---- HARRISON Mark, 1832-1899 Clarinda, wife, 1835 ---- BUTLER Ephram W., 28 Mar 1828 - 12 Nov 1897 Lydia, wife, 25 Jul 1835 - 25 Jul 1917 COXE Marvin (no dates given) Mary J., 8 Feb 1826 - 23 Apr 1910 MOORE C. K. & N. G (no dates given) Ada E., 11 Nov 1894, ae 10 yrs, 2 mos, 11 dys Romanzo, 23 Dec 1829 - 3 (8?) May, 1866, Enlisted as a volunteer, 11 Aug 1862 Elisa, wife, 6 Jun 1832 - 26 Oct 1870, lost at Battle of Rocky Fa_ed Ridge (sic) MARVIN F. A., 8 Jun 1820 - 24 Sep 1902 Mary S., 11 Jan 1858, 9 yrs, 10 mos, 13 dys Elizabeth, wife, 2 Nov 1818 - 29 May 1894 A. C., 22 Sep 1842 Ella M., wife, 23 Sep 1844 Oren F., 6 Jan 1858, ae 4 yrs, 10 mos, 22 dys Abner C., 1842-1924 Ella M.,, 1844-1913 Enoch, 25 Aug 1850, ae 74 yrs SPALDING L. C. & M. S. (no dates given) Frankie J., dau, 20 Oct 1869, ae 6 mos Sidney T., son, 16 Sep 1862, ae 4 yrs, 3 dys Alice J., dau., 29 Sep 1862 Cyrus E., son, 3 Oct 1862, 9 mos Marahal T., 20 Oct 1867, ae 1 yr, 1 mo, 17 dys LOUNSBURY Thomas, 10 Aug 1855 - 11 May 1926 Lillie B., wife, 19 Jun 1859 - 4 Feb 1902 PUTMAN Arthus H., 19 (18?) Oct 1871 Rose G., wife, 26 Feb 1876 CARNES S., (no dates given) Martha, 23 Jan 1893, ae 54 yrs JACKSON Rev. M. A., (no dates given) Spencer, 1840-1922 ACKLEY Eli, (no dates given) Polly, 14 Nov 1862, 82 yrs McKOON Albert I., 1846-1926 Helen COLE, 1848-1881 SHERMAN S. E., 28 Aug 1866 Helen M., wife, 18 Jun 1854 - 12 Aug 1894 McKEON Rev. D. W., 23 Jun 1811, Columbus, Herkimer Co., NY; d. 4 Jan 1871, Olean, NY Jane, wife, 1816-1904 MELVIN C. D. (no dates given) Antonette, 7 Aug 1865, ae 40 yrs, 6 mos BRYANT Freeman, 1 Feb 1860, 67 yrs Orren, 12 Mar 1877, 59 yrs, 2 mos, 4 dys Sheldon, 23 Mar 1812 - 2 Jan 1886 Ruth, 22 Oct 1817 - 4 Oct 1902 Mary, wife, 1845-1900 WHITTLESEY John Pratt, 1845 -1904 CHASE Nathaniel (no dates given) Abagale, wife, 15 Feb 1849, 25 yrs, 1 mo, 14 dys CLARK H. S., 8 Dec 1830 - 12 Sep 1898, 154 Reg. flag Catharine L, wife, 8 Mar 1835 - 4 Jul 1870 Hiram, 17 Dec 1801 - 30 Mar 1885 Achan B.(?), wife, 25 Feb 1805 - 1 Apr 1855 Mary A., dau., 8 Mar 1833 - 20 Mar 1863 M. Jane, 19 Oct 1835 - 1 Nov 1888 H. S., wife (no dates given) Jane L., 7 Jan 1836 - 30 Mar 1885 H. S., wife (no dates given) Arthur J., son, 22 Aug 1876 - 16 Feb 1879 BOILLET Francis & Elizabeth (no other information) Harry T. M., 3 Apr 1857, 20 yrs, 11 mos, 3 dys Ella M., 2 Dec 1861, 10 yrs, 9 mos CHASE Orrin (no dates given) Sophia, wife, 10 May 1834, 19 yrs, 1 mo, 10 dys Frankie, of A. & M., (no dates given) Alonzo, of A. & M., (no dates given) THOMAS Shepherd N., 1839-1918, Co. A., 164 Regt., flag Eva _., 20 Jun 1876, ae 33 yrs, 8 mos, 21 dys Isaac, 30 Aug 1867, 74 yrs, 5 mos, 10 dys Eunice, wife, 16 Jul 1869, 67 yrs Laura G., dau., 12 Feb 1845, 21 yrs, 10 mos, 16 dys Edna F., dau., 6 Mar 1865, 5 mos, 20 dys Willie W., son of C. & S., 9 Mar 1871, 7 yrs, 10 mos, 2 dys Charles, 1828-1895 Sarah, wife, 1841-1895 SALISBURY Elizabeth T., 1835-1895 PHILLIPS Juliana C., 22 Jan, 1816 - 14 Jun 1886 CHASE Robert, 31 May 1836, 43 yrs Sarah, wife, 26 May 1871, 74 yrs, 9 mos Orinn R., 13 Oct 1848 (no other information) Lorenzo D., 29 Nov 1844, 32 yrs, 6 mos, 4 dys Robert, 31 May 1843, 43 yrs Lomas L., -- Oct 1851 Moses, 14 Feb 1849, 63 yrs, 4 mos, 22 dys Porter J., 7 Jan 1853, 36 yrs, 3 mos, 6 dys GARDNER Orula, 4 Mar 1880, 59 ys, 10 mos, 8 dys Horatio (flag) (no other information) Orrilla, wife, 13 Oct 1869, 44 yrs SEE Margaret Brown, 1851-1924